| 1. | Rev. Robert Hickman | 1863 – 1886 |
| 2. | Rev. Bird. J. Wilkins | 1886 – 1887 |
| 3. | Rev. William Gray | 1887 – 1889 |
| 4. | Rev. Lewis C. Sheafe | 1889 – 1893 |
| 5. | Rev. Robinson C. Quarles | 1893 – 1895 |
| 6. | Rev. J. D. Underwood | 1895 – 1896 |
| 7. | Rev. B. B. Hill | 1897 – 1898 |
| 8. | Rev. D. S. Orner | 1898 – 1900 |
| 9. | Rev. W.D. Carter | 1900 – 1909 |
| 10. | Rev. E. W. McDonald | 1910 – 1914 |
| 11. | Rev. B. N. Murrell | 1914 – 1918 |
| 12. | Rev. B. H. Hodge | 1918 – 1920 |
| 13. | Rev. Lee Ward Harris | 1922 – 1938 |
| 14. | Rev. S. E. Ware | 1941 – 1944 |
| 15. | Rev. Floyd Massey, Jr. | 1944 – 1965 |
| 16. | Rev. Dr. Arthur L. Whitaker | 1966 – 1970 |
| 17. | Rev. Dr. Amos C. Brown, Sr. | 1970 – 1976 |
| 18. | Rev. Dr. Earl F. Miller | 1977 – 1992 |
| 19. | Rev. Jack Thomas (Interim) | 1992 – 1993 |
| 20. | Rev. Thomas E. Fantroy | 1993 – 1996 |
| 21. | Rev. Dr. Roy Thompson (Interim) | 1996 – 1998 |
| 22. | Rev. Dr. Robert L. Stephens, Sr. | 1999 – 2001 |
| 23. | Rev. Randolph Thompson (Interim) | 2002 – 2004 |
| 24. | Rev. Dr. Charles L. Gill, Jr. | 2004 – Present |
